Wye Oak Tavern is the best restaurant in Frederick, Maryland. Created by Frederick natives Bryan and Michael Voltaggio, it sits in the former chapel of the Visitation Hotel in downtown Frederick.

Nicole and I first dined here in February 2025, during an overnight stay at the hotel. We have returned several times since, and we still consider it the best restaurant in town.

This review covers the bar, the dining room, the menu, and what we ordered. We are staying at the hotel again in November 2026 and will update it with anything new.

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Wye Oak Tavern at a Glance

Quick Facts
LocationInside the Visitation Hotel, 211 E Church St, Frederick, MD 21701
ChefsBryan and Michael Voltaggio
CuisineTavern fare and steakhouse cuts with a local focus
HoursDinner only
Price range$$$$
ReservationsOpenTable (a must on weekends)
MenuSee the current menu
DressNo formal dress code; we recommend upscale casual
Phone+1 240-931-1120
WebsiteWyeOakTavern.com
Instagram@wyeoaktavern

Wye Oak Tavern at The Visitation Hotel

Watch Our Visit to the Visitation Hotel and Wye Oak Tavern!

The article has lots more details on our dining experience at the Wye Oak Tavern.  Be sure also to read our article describing our entire visit to the Visitation Hotel Frederick. 

But check out the video below of Nicole and Glenn’s recent tour of both properties!

A New Culinary Creation by Frederick's Voltaggio Brothers

Bryan Voltaggio and his brother Michael are celebrity chefs, successful restaurant entrepreneurs, and Frederick, Maryland originals.  Each owns several restaurants, and they jointly own Voltaggio Brothers Steakhouse at MGM National Harbor.

Bryan, in particular, has significantly influenced the Frederick restaurant scene. He has opened several establishments, including Showroom (originally named Family Meal) and Thacher and Rye.

Bryan and Michael Voltaggio have reunited to create Wye Oak Tavern, the on-site restaurant for the Visitation Hotel, a Marriott Tribute property that has been converted from a historic convent. 

Despite having opened restaurants across the country, this project in their hometown holds special significance for the Voltaggio brothers.

Photo Credit:  foodnetwork.com
Photo Credit: foodnetwork.com

This new restaurant combines a menu focused on local, featuring classic dishes from places like Thacher and Rye, and a dining room that was originally a chapel.

Put it all together and have a very special dining experience.

a Marble Bar with Black Chairs Sits Beneath a Large Religious Painting at Visitation Hotel Frederick Md Framed by White Columns and Two Angel Statues a Stained Glass Window of a Saint Blends Ornate Church Architecture with a Modern Bar Setup

I must admit that even before visiting Wye Oak, I was a huge fan of Voltaggio’s restaurants in Frederick, which are among my favorites.

A New, Local Culinary Powerhouse, Extraordinary in Many Ways

A visit to Wye Oak is nothing short of transformative, as Nicole and I discovered on our first trip. The bar exudes vibrancy.  And that striking altar.

The dining area, housed in a converted chapel, creates an atmosphere that, for a restaurant, is hard to wrap your head around.  

Before you even look at a menu, you will know you are at a place.

The menu takes to heart the tavern designation, serving a burger and beers.  But Wye Oak combines this with fine dining options, as refined as any restaurant in the city.

We love ‘local,’ and no one has done more to promote this than places like Showroom and Thacher and Rye.  The Wye Oak Tavern continues this tradition, serving local spirits, local beers, local beef, and, of course, rockfish and crab cakes.

A Fabulous Bar Already Making Headlines

Every great hotel needs a bar, and Wye Oak delivers.  The bar is worth a visit alone, and my guess is soon, on weekends, the Wye Oak Tavern bar will be flocked with locals even more than hotel guests.

a Grand Bar Reminiscent of the Best Bars in Frederick Stands Before a White Marble Altar with Columns and Angelic Statues Bottles Line Glass Shelves Beneath a Classical Painting While Arched Windows Illuminate the Elegant High Ceilinged Room

Before we dive into the cocktails and spirits, it’s important to note that this bar is exceptionally unique.

Like the restaurant, the bar is located in the academy’s original chapel. The chapel altar has been transformed into the bar itself, and a significant portion of it still stands prominently behind the bottles.

(Some residents of Frederick are calling for a change, but we think it’s pretty cool.)

A Love At First Sight Bar and Cocktail Menu

Once you’re done staring, you can finally check out the drink menu, and it’s a good one.  The cocktails are celebrity chef-worthy, but the star of the drink menu is the martinis.

If you enjoy martinis (like Nicole, not Glenn), try one of five unique concoctions. For instance, the Wye Oak Martini is made with Old Raj Gin and Gonzalez Byass Extra Seco Vermouth.

(note:  these martinis are big enough to share).

The Vibe at Wye Oak Tavern

The stunning stained glass windows, the altar positioned behind the bar, the soaring cathedral ceilings, and the majestic pipe organ on the second level. 

There’s no getting around how much the former sacred aspects of the building affect the vibe of the Wye Oak Venue.

a Spacious Elegant Restaurant with High Ceilings Chandeliers and a Balconyperfect for Guests from Boutique Hotels Frederick Md Soft Lighting Wooden Floors and Classical Details Create a Warm Atmosphere As Diners Enjoy Meals and Attentive Service

Sounds seem to echo and create a borderline boisterous atmosphere.  Though Nicole and I perfectly enjoyed our table for two.

The restaurant has an upper level (which we will request next time) and several side event rooms.  And somehow, it all works.  

The Wye Oak is a restaurant you visit for the food, the drinks, and the cuisine.  But you also visit because it’s a place.

The Wye Oak Tavern Menu - Steakhouse Mastery and Very Local

For any food-focused visitor to Frederick, I’ve always consistently recommended dinner at Thacher and Rye and brunch at the Showroom.  Both are quintessentially Frederick.

After one visit to Wye Oak Tavern, it feels the same.  Chef Voltaggio again makes this restaurant feel connected to Frederick and Maryland. 

You can eat well and have fun merely with the appetizers and shareables section of the Wye Oak menu.  Nicole and I took a side glance at the pimento cheese served with the Surryano Ham appetizer at the table next to us, and followed suit.

Crab cakes, steak tartare, and oysters in our immediate vicinity also caught our eye and were very tempting as well.

a Restaurant Table Set with Plates of Grilled Steak Yorkshire Pudding Roasted Broccoli Sauce and a Glass of Red Wine at Wye Oakthe Best Steakhouse Frederick Md Has to Offerwhere the Food is Artistically Arranged on Elegant White Dishes

This “tavern” seemingly compels you towards ordering a steak.  Head straight to the Our Meats section and begin wrestling with your decision.

The Prime Rib is the signature dish.  In my case, I again ordered local, choosing the Grass Fed Prime Beef Ribeye from Roseda Farm.  Nicole went Filet Mignon.  Special meal!

a Smiling Server in a Suit Presents a Bottle of Red Wine to a Guest at the Best Steakhouse Frederick Md Where Tall White Columns Frame the Restaurant the Table Features San Pellegrino a Cocktail and a Plate with a Napkin

It must be mentioned that Steven, the in-house sommelier, helped make our meal epic by assisting us in selecting a fabulous Bordeaux red!  

(The Wye Oak wine list is yet another thing to love here).

What We Ordered at Wye Oak Tavern

  • To start: pimento cheese with Surryano ham.
  • Glenn: the grass-fed prime beef ribeye from Roseda Farm.
  • Nicole: the filet mignon.
  • Wine: a Bordeaux red, chosen with help from Steven, the sommelier.
  • From the bar: the martini list has five options, and they are big enough to share.

The prime rib is the signature dish, and it is on our list for next time.

Get The Full Experience - Stay at the Visitation Hotel!

If you are a Frederick local or visiting Frederick, then the Wye Oak Tavern has immediately become a must-visit restaurant.  For the bar, the cuisine, or the overall dining experience, put it on your list.

But it’s hard to separate Wye Oak from its associated venue – The Visitation Hotel.  In fact, the two complement each other in offering locals or visitors a memorable experience in downtown Frederick. 

Historic Red Brick Facade of the Visitation Hotel in Downtown Frederick Md with Wye Oak Tavern Signage Tall Arched Stained Glass Windows and a Holiday Wreath

Consider turning your visit at the Wye Oak Tavern into a night or weekend at this fabulous property right in downtown Frederick.

What Else You Need to Know About Wye Oak Tavern

  • Reservations on OpenTable (a must on weekends)

Wye Oak Tavern - FAQs

Wye Oak Tavern was created by chefs Bryan and Michael Voltaggio, brothers who grew up in Frederick.

It is inside the Visitation Hotel at 211 E Church St in downtown Frederick, in the building’s former chapel.

No. Wye Oak Tavern is open for dinner only. Hotel guests can get coffee and breakfast at Acorn Provisions, the cafe next door.

We recommend one, especially on weekends. Reservations are on OpenTable.

It combines tavern fare, such as a burger and beers, with steakhouse cuts and Maryland favorites like rockfish and crab cakes. The prime rib is the signature dish.

There is no formal dress code. We recommend upscale casual.

author avatar
Glenn VanLandingham Co-founder, EpicBend & EpicFrederick
Glenn has been exploring the areas around Bend, Oregon and Frederick, Maryland for 20 years. With his wife Nicole, he personally visits every restaurant, trail, winery, and golf course they write about. He's traveled to all 50 states and 30+ countries, but Bend and Frederick are home.